Is it plagiarism?
ZXNet echo conference «music.zx»
Hello, All
At CC'2006, karbofos' track did not pass the preselection due to the fact that it was allegedly
plagiarism on the track mmcm'a -rescue me.
I am attaching both tracks and asking you to take part in the voting - how would you rate it.
File: Krba-Classified.rar http://zx.pk.ru/attachment.php?attachmentid=3681
File: mmcm-rescue me.rar http://zx.pk.ru/attachment.php?attachmentid=3682
Hello diver
And who is worse off from this? After all, this is an ordinary Spectrum, who wants what?
sculpts. I like the mmcm option better.
I also used to like to mix up instrumentals into melodies. I
I received incredible pleasure from this. But Karbofos even has different notes
music
Hello Striker
the topic is nonsense. You can plagiarize so that no one will notice, or you can plagiarize it out of ignorance
1 in 1 almost completely repeat.
let Karb himself say how he wrote the track and what he thinks and that’s all. and voting
to arrange is empty.
Hello Striker
There is so much music on the spec, and so few possibilities, that it is difficult to find a track on any
what is different, what is similar. A man wrote a track, why should he break through the entire database?
Bulbs before sending your work to some party?
Hello, karbofos
Here's my opinion. We all learned from the masters, adopting techniques from them, developing them
and adding something of your own. I don’t consider Karbofos’ melody to be plagiarism, because... idea there
independent. I listened to both tunes with pleasure.
Hello, key-jee
in general, the technique of sound production is borrowed from mmtsm, the theme is completely
invented by me.
There is no plagiarism here, and I could not even think that they would accuse me
in this.
There are similarities, of course, but solely due to similar technical
techniques.